Ohio v. Kinney

Brief of Amicus Curiae, Office of the Ohio Public Defender [and the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers] in Support of Appellant, David C. Kinney, Jr.

Brief filed: 02/18/2020


Ohio v. Kinney

Supreme Court of Ohio; Case No. 2019-1103

Prior Decision

Decision below 2019 WL 2774306 (Ohio App. 7 Dist. June 28, 2019)


The prohibition in R.C. 2953.08(D)(3)--which is entirely unique to Ohio--is most accurately understood as a legislative oversight with severe unintended consequences. But even if not, it is unconstitutional on both cruel-and-unusual-punishment and equal-protection grounds. Amici Curiae urge this Court to provide meaningful appellate review of sentences for aggravated murder in Ohio.

Coronavirus Resources

NACDL to Focus on Service and Support for Members, Clients, and Community Throughout Virus Emergency

Learn More


Peter Galyardt, Assistant Ohio Public Defender, Columbus, OH; Stephanie F. Kessler, Pinales, Stachler, Young & Burrell Co., LPA, Cincinnati, OH; Kristina Supler NACDL, Cleveland, OH.

Explore keywords to find information