United States v. McIver
Case Details
- Case No.: 2:25-cr-0288
- Case Filed: June 10, 2025
- Jurisdiction: D.N.J.
- Charges: 18 U.S.C. 111
- Judge: Semper, Jamel, K.
- US Attorney: McCarren, Mark J.
- Defendant(s): McIver, LaMonica
- Defense Attorney: Fishman, Paul J.
Key Topics in the Case
Case Analysis
Login is required to view the "Case Analysis" section of the Case Tracker. This content is limited to defense practitioners. Please log in or create a free NACDL account to continue. Non-NACDL members will be prompted to complete a brief attorney attestation form before access is granted.
Case Files
-
ECF: 1 - 05/19/25 - Government - Complaint
Complaint -
ECF: 12 - 06/10/25 - Government - Indictment
Indictment -
ECF: 19 - 08/15/25 - Defense - Motion to Dismiss
Motion to Dismiss Based on Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 20 - 08/15/25 - Motion to Dismiss
Defendant's Motion to Dismiss for Vindictive Prosecution -
ECF: 44 - 11/13/25 - Court - Court Orders
Opinion Denying Both Motion to Dismiss for Vindictive and Selective Prosecution and Motion to Dismiss for Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 45 - 11/13/25 - Court - Court Orders
Court Order Denying Defendant's Motion to Dismiss for Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 51 - 12/09/25 - Defense - Motion to Dismiss
Defense Supplemental Motion to Dismiss for Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 52 - 12/09/25 - Government - Motion to Dismiss
Government Opposition to Defense Supplemental Motion to Dismiss for Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 60 - 12/29/25 - Defense - Other
Defendant's Notice of Appeal of Court Order Denying Motion to Dismiss for Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 63 - 01/05/26 - Court - Court Orders
Court Opinion Denying Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Count Two on Grounds of Legislative Immunity -
ECF: 74 - 10/15/26 - Defense - Motions for/against Discovery - Defendant's Supplemental Motion to Compel Discovery
Defendant's Supplemental Motion to Compel Discovery
Argument(s)
Interlocutory - Date Filed 01/20/26 - 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals
See the Analysis section for appeal analysis.
Appeal Details
- Case Number: 26-1122
- Date Filed: 01/20/2026
- Jurisdiction: 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals
- Type: Interlocutory
- Status: Decided
Panel: Ambro, Thomas L.; Freeman, Arianna J.; Porter, David J.
Questions Presented
1. Whether the district court should have dismissed the indictment because the Speech or Debate Clause immunizes Congresswoman McIver for her conduct while performing legislative acts. 2. Whether the district court should have dismissed the indictment because the separation of powers precludes charging Congresswoman McIver for official acts. 3. Whether the district court should have dismissed the indictment or, at a minimum, ordered discovery because Congresswoman McIver is being prosecuted on account of her protected expression, oversight activity, and political affiliation.
Result on Appeal
In a 49-page filing, a divided three-judge panel largely rejected McIver’s bid to have her case dismissed, holding that two of the three counts charging assault on a federal agent are not shielded by congressional immunity. Writing for the majority, Judge Cindy Chung reasoned that the Speech or Debate Clause doesn’t provide blanket protection over everything related to the legislative process, and that McIver’s physical contact with the officer outside of the ICE detention center she was there to inspect as a Congressperson was “unambiguously non-legislative.” The panel drew a distinction: it found that her inspection of Delaney Hall itself was protected under the Speech or Debate Clause, but her intervention in Mayor Baraka’s arrest, which is what led to the assault charged in the indictment was not. The panel sent Count Three back with directions for the district court to (1) separately determine whether the conduct charged in that count includes any legislative acts, and (2) if so, decide whether the count can still stand once any protected conduct is stripped out. Finally, the Court did not reach Congresswomen’s McIver’s claims for vindictive or selective prosecution, holding that the district court’s denial of those claims were not subject to an immediate appeal.
Appeal Files
-
02/19/26 - ECF: 14 - Motion - Opposition to government's motion to dismiss part of the appeal
Opposition to government's motion to dismiss part of the appeal -
03/30/26 - ECF: 27 - Appellant's Opening Brief
Appellant's Opening Brief -
04/06/26 - ECF: 35 - Brief - Amicus Brief in Support of Defendant by Former Members of Congress
Amicus Brief in Support of Defendant by Former Members of Congress -
10/09/26 - ECF: 71 - Other - Petition for Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc
Petition for Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc -
05/21/26 - ECF: 51 - Brief - McIver Reply Brief
McIver Reply Brief -
04/06/26 - ECF: 31 - Brief - Brief for Amicus Former January 6 Prosecutors on Behalf of McIver
Brief for Amicus Former January 6 Prosecutors on Behalf of McIver -
04/06/26 - ECF: 34 - Brief - Amicus Brief In Support of Defendant by ACLU, NAACP, and NWLC
Amicus Brief In Support of Defendant by ACLU, NAACP, and NWLC -
02/26/26 - ECF: 15 - Motion - Government Reply in Support of its Motion to Dismiss Part of Appeal
Government Reply in Support of its Motion to Dismiss Part of Appeal -
05/05/26 - ECF: 45 - Brief - Government (Appellee) Brief
Government (Appellee) Brief -
02/09/26 - ECF: 12 - Motion - Government Motion for Court to Dismiss McIver Appeal of Court Order Denying Motion to Dismiss For Vindictive Prosecution
Government Motion for Court to Dismiss McIver Appeal of Court Order Denying Motion to Dismiss For Vindictive Prosecution -
08/26/26 - ECF: 62 - Opinion - Court Opinion Affirming District Court Denial of McIver MTD
Court Opinion Affirming District Court Denial of McIver MTD
Suggest a Case
Know of a federal case that departs from traditional enforcement norms? Let us know.
Suggest a CaseResources
Case Tracker Feedback
Help us improve the Unusual Case Tracker by sharing your experience and suggestions.
Take Brief Survey